Emmerdale fans are convinced Anthony Fox has a second secret child in the village

Emmerdale delivered a stunning plot twist recently when Anthony Fox, played by Nicholas Day, met a tragic end after his dark past as a child abuser was exposed.

However, some viewers of the ITV soap speculate that Anthony might have been concealing another shocking secret – that Ruby has a sibling living in the village.

The dramatic confrontation unfolded when Aaron, driven by rage and tears, faced off against Anthony after discovering the horrific truth about his abuse of Ruby.

The terminally ill Anthony, desperate to avoid imprisonment, resorted to taunting Aaron about his own traumatic experiences, pushing Aaron to his limits.

In a fit of fury, Aaron brutally assaulted Anthony, leaving him lifeless on the depot floor. Upon returning home, a visibly shaken Aaron confided in his partner, John Sugden, about the violent encounter, revealing, “I nearly killed him.”

Ruby doesn’t know Anthony is dead (Image: ITV)

John took charge of the situation, suggesting they return to the depot, only to find Anthony deceased.

With Aaron overcome with anxiety, John volunteered to dispose of the body, taking control of the dire circumstances.

Emmerdale newcomer John, who joined the iconic Sugden family last year, has kept his past shrouded in mystery, with only his army background coming to light, reports Leeds Live.

However, eagle-eyed fans are speculating that John might actually be Ruby’s real brother and could even be responsible for Antony’s demise.

Emmerdale fans have a new theory about John Sugden’s past (Image: ITV)

We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you’ve consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our Privacy Policy

One fan took to Facebook to share their theory: “I think Anthony killer is John? Who turns out to be Ruby brother. Hope I have names right.”

Another chimed in questioning a potential sibling connection: “A brother has been mentioned I am sure?”, while another suggested an illicit affair with: “Love child maybe.”

Meanwhile, one viewer doubts John’s honesty about his lineage, stating: “I think he’s lying.”